US abortion policy is ‘extremist hate’ and ‘torture’, says UN commissioner

Trump administration’s ban on terminations is a crisis directed at women, warns Kate Gilmore

By Julia Conley | 4 June 2019
Common Dreams

United Nations deputy high commissioner for human rights, Kate Gilmore. (Photo: Fabrice Coffrini / AFP / Getty Images)

A top United Nations official on human rights said Tuesday that the recent escalation in attacks on reproductive rights in the U.S. must be categorized in the same way as other many attacks on basic rights—as part of an “extremist hate” campaign.

“We have not called it out in the same way we have other forms of extremist hate, but this is gender-based violence against women, no question,” Kate Gilmore, deputy high commissioner for human rights, told The Guardian.

Denying women the right to abortion care is tantamount to “torture,” Gilmore added.

“It’s a deprivation of a right to health,” she said, noting that a panel of nine U.N. human rights experts determined recently that prohibiting abortion amounts to a violation of fundamental rights.

The human rights deputy commissioner is speaking out amid the passage of increasingly extreme anti-abortion restrictions in the U.S. In recent weeks, Alabama, Georgia, Ohio, and several other states have passed laws banning the procedure after fetal cardiac activity can be detected—in many cases, before a woman even knows she’s pregnant. Louisiana and Alabama legislators refused to include exceptions for victims of rape or incest in their recent bans.

“It’s clear it’s torture,” Gilmore told The Guardian. “This is a crisis. It’s a crisis directed at women.”

Gilmore’s comments came days after she spoke at an event hosted by The Guardian and the Center for Reproductive Rights, where her demand that “We need to stop tolerating the intolerable” was praised by global reproductive rights advocates.

Gilmore pointed to a well-organized and well-funded coalition of anti-choice groups which have recently managed to frame the national debate about reproductive rights around the notion that viable, healthy fetuses are aborted in the third trimester, decrying so-called “late-term abortion”—a term that is not recognized in medical field—as “infanticide.”

In reality, just over one percent of abortions take place after 21 weeks of gestation, and women often obtain abortions at this stage due to fetal abnormalities that weren’t detected earlier or because continuing the pregnancy would pose health risks.

“This is a lie that encourages conservatives to regard pregnant women and medical caregivers as potential ruthless killers who should be hemmed in with yet more laws targeting them,” Rebecca Solnit wrote in The Guardian on Monday. “While a lot of older abortion lies were distortions and exaggerations, this one is a complete and dangerous fabrication.”

Such lies, Gilmore said, have created an urgent need for policymakers and pro-choice advocates to ensure safe abortion care is accessible to women.

“We have to stand with the evidence and facts and in solidarity with women, and in particular young women and minority women who are really under the gun,” Gilmore said.

Kirsten Gillibrand: If Trump wants a fight with women, he’s got it

What Alabama’s abortion ban really aims to do

Anticipating the end of Roe v. Wade, states are passing new abortion laws

Be sure to ‘like’ us on Facebook


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here